Abandoned Ship On the Horizon – the forever sea (Joshua Phillip Johnson) – unpopular opinion time!

Ahoy there me mateys!  I received this fantasy eARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.  So here be me honest musings . . .

Title: the forever sea

Author: Joshua Phillip Johnson

Publisher: DAW

Publication Date: TODAY!! (hardback/e-book)

ISBN: 978-0756417031

Source: NetGalley

The Forever Sea (The Forever Sea, #1)

I really, really wanted to love this book.  Just look at the beautiful cover!  It features the sea!  Pirates!  Female Captains!  Magic!  Sadly, I had to abandon ship at 50% cause the story wasn’t working.  I even spoiled the ending by reading other reviews to see if I should push through in case it got better.  I chose to stop.

The Pros:

  • The Setting:  This features a sea that is not water but grass!  There is a world beneath the grass but humans don’t know what exists there besides monsters.  Cool concept.  I particularly liked that instead of fishing, sailors sail around to harvest different types of grass and plants.
  • The Magic:  I really enjoyed the idea of the hearth fires helping to run the ship.  I adored the bird-caller having feathered friends help with navigation.
  • Lots of female characters:  There are all female sailing crews.  They do not pine for men but rather for adventure and loot.  Arrr!
  • Water Subplot: I liked the idea of the water shortage on Arcadia and how it affected the social structure and rules of the city.

The Cons:

  • The Main Character:  Kindred (horrible name) ended up making me upset with her actions.  She was selfish, impulsive, reckless, and irrational.
  • The Framing Device: I hated this.  It takes place far in a dystopian future where a supernatural type being is telling the history of the world.  It was a boring beginning to the novel and interrupted story flow every time.
  • The Magic:  While the magic ideas were fun, they really didn’t make any sense in terms of how they functioned or what the rules were.  The author chose to make Kindred learn by instinct.  This made the magic seem like gibberish.
  • Repetitive Themes: I got tired of the author making the same points over and over again.  Kindred’s unorthodox and reckless use of hearth fire.  How her training was both truncated and haphazard.  Her unusual love for and connection to the sea.  How she is Special.  How Kindred’s grandmother was a Larger than Life Figure.  Humans causing environmental devastation.  Seriously this book needed trimming.
  • The Plot: The story did not make sense to me in the slightest.  Kindred chooses to lie to everyone and go on a hazardous crusade regardless of the consequences to those she cares about.  The reasons for this abrupt turn around of her beliefs were silly.  The evil villain had lame politics of “power at any cost” and felt completely flat.  Much of that subplot felt forced.  I didn’t even get to the actual pirate town because I was so bored and the pacing was so slow.  When the giant wrym battle happened I was perplexed at how uninteresting it was.  I should have loved the life on the sea but the events in the story were all too coincidental or too simple.  Character motivations also seemed petty or nonsensical.

This book appealed in concepts but it didn’t work for me at all in the end.  To the grass wyrms it goes.  Arrrr!

So lastly . . .

Thank you DAW!

Goodreads has this to say about the novel:

On the never-ending, miles-high expanse of prairie grasses known as the Forever Sea, Kindred Greyreach, hearthfire keeper and sailor aboard harvesting vessel The Errant, is just beginning to fit in with the crew of her new ship when she receives devastating news. Her grandmother–The Marchess, legendary captain and hearthfire keeper–has stepped from her vessel and disappeared into the sea.

But the note she leaves Kindred suggests this was not an act of suicide. Something waits in the depths, and the Marchess has set out to find it.

To follow in her grandmother’s footsteps, Kindred must embroil herself in conflicts bigger than she could imagine: a water war simmering below the surface of two cultures; the politics of a mythic pirate city floating beyond the edges of safe seas; battles against beasts of the deep, driven to the brink of madness; and the elusive promise of a world below the waves.

Kindred finds that she will sacrifice almost everything–ship, crew, and a life sailing in the sun–to discover the truth of the darkness that waits below the Forever Sea.

To visit the author’s website go to:

Joshua Phillip Johnson – Author

To buy the novel go to:

the forever sea – Book 1

To add to Goodreads go to:

Yer Ports for Plunder List

23 thoughts on “Abandoned Ship On the Horizon – the forever sea (Joshua Phillip Johnson) – unpopular opinion time!

  1. Ha, the grasswyrm battle was when this really came together for me 😀

    …I share some of your other criticisms (the Arcadian villain isn’t really the villain, he’s a plot device and it shows), but I like Johnson’s ambition, and thankfully his execution wasn’t as far off for me as for you 😉 Better luck with the next new author you tackle!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Urg! I hate it when I pick up a book all fired up by the brilliant premise, just for it to fall in a heap because I cannot stand the protagonist, or there are too many silly plot holes for me to stomach. There are a handful of well known, highly successful authors I won’t touch with a bargepole, because I HATE their books:)).

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I was hesitant to pick this up, then I read Andreas’s glowing review and then read yours! 😂 No more closer to a decision, it seems! Sorry this didn’t work for you – next book will be better!


  4. I hadn’t heard of this one before, but the concept does sound interesting. However, given that there are so many books on my TBR already, I think this one won’t be one I add to my list even though the concept sounds neat. The issues you point out with it are already bugging me even just from reading your review. 😉

    Liked by 1 person

      1. I’m still here, Cap! Just behind on my reading haha. I think I might post a rant somewhere about Ready Player Two 🤣 not sure yet though.

        I was drawn in by the cover of this one, but it’s definitely one I’ll skip on. Trying to get better at not just buying every book I see!


  5. I almost didn’t read this because I just started this book last night. It is going by very slowly (on my Kindle watching how slow the percentages change🤣) but I am captivated by the world. We shall see!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.