Walk the Plank – anyone (Charles Soule) – unpopular opinion time!!

Ahoy there mateys!  It is with a sad heart that I have to make the first read of the year walk the plank.  I really didn’t want to start out 2020 in this way but alas.  I was very much looking forward to this read as I enjoyed the previous novel I read by the author and the crew has been saying good things about this one.  When me library hold came in just in time for the new year, I thought it was a sign of good things to come.  Blast!

The problems started from the very beginning.  There be two timelines in this novel and the transitions between them were jarring and confusing.  The technology in this book deals with “the flash” where ye can put yer consciousness into another person’s body.  Cool if creepy.  In the past timeline, ye follow the scientist who created the technology, Gabby.  In the future timeline, the flash has transformed society.  Ye follow Annami who is using the dark sides of the technology for revenge.  The illegal uses of the flash were the most interesting.

In addition to the awkward time shifts, I ended up hating Gabby.  I was sympathetic to her situation at first.  She is running out of money, is desperate for her project to work, and the loan sharks are coming to get her.  I get that she wants to maintain control of her experiment but she shouldn’t have signed for that loan.  Once the action ramps up, Gabby makes one bad decision after another and continually puts her family in danger.  Her pride is annoying and misplaced.  She wants to change the world in any way she can (doesn’t matter) and she also wants EVERYONE to know her name.  Aye, she be smart but she has no common sense.

While the concepts of the flash were interesting, I found meself asking too many questions about inconsistencies and ramifications of the technology.  I understood that it had changed the world but the plot seemed to have holes and too many coincidences for me.  The tech never felt real but seemed more like something out of a bad sci-fi channel made for tv movie.  The more I discussed the technologies possibilities with the First Mate, the more problems I found and the grumpier I got.

And I hated the twist through the entire ridiculous ending.  The book is split into multiple parts and I liked two and three the best.  I get the book’s appeal but it didn’t work for me.  To the sharks it goes.  Arrrr!

Goodreads had this to say about the novel:

Charles Soule brings his signature knowledge—and wariness–of technology to his sophomore novel set in a realistic future about a brilliant female scientist who creates a technology that allows for the transfer of human consciousness between bodies, and the transformations this process wreaks upon the world.

Inside a barn in Ann Arbor, Michigan, a scientist searching for an Alzheimer’s cure throws a switch—and finds herself mysteriously transported into her husband’s body. What begins as a botched experiment will change her life—and the world—forever…

Over two decades later, all across the planet, “flash” technology allows individuals the ability to transfer their consciousness into other bodies for specified periods, paid, registered and legal. Society has been utterly transformed by the process, from travel to warfare to entertainment; “Be anyone with Anyone” the tagline of the company offering this ultimate out-of-body experience. But beyond the reach of the law and government regulators is a sordid black market called the darkshare, where desperate “vessels” anonymously rent out their bodies, no questions asked for any purpose – sex, drugs, crime… or worse.

Anyone masterfully interweaves the present-day story of the discovery and development of the flash with the gritty tale of one woman’s crusade to put an end to the darkness it has brought to the world twenty-five years after its creation. Like Blade Runner crossed with Get Out, Charles Soule’s thought-provoking work of speculative fiction takes us to a world where identity, morality, and technology collide

To visit the author’s website go to:

Charles Soule – Author

To buy the novel please visit:

anyone – Book

To add to Goodreads go to:

Yer Ports for Plunder List

Previous Log Entries for this Author

the oracle year (Captain’s Log – Sci-Fi)

10 thoughts on “Walk the Plank – anyone (Charles Soule) – unpopular opinion time!!

  1. Sometimes the description of a book creates expectations that are not met by reality once we get into the story, and that’s what seems to have happened with this one: I know what it means to be sorely disappointed by a novel that everyone else praises, but to me it’s like a sort of… chemical reaction, as it happens between people – with some we can strike an instant friendship, with others it’s instant dislike.
    Better luck next time, Captain!! 🙂


  2. 2 different confusing timelines and a main character you can’t connect with? Nah, that doesn’t sound like it’s it! Good on you for getting rid of it!

    May there be better books on the horizon for you!!


  3. Ah, too bad. I liked The Oracle Year and was looking forward to this one, but it sounds like I can find a better use of my time… Gabby sounds unpleasant to read about. Great review!


  4. Pity you didn’t like it. Interesting aside, though, my first read of 2020 also walked the plank! I started the year with a DNF review. I’m hoping that just means we’ll be more appreciative of the good books we read the rest of the year. 😉


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.