Shiver me Timbers! The 2019 Hugo Finalists – Part Three – Best Short Story

Ahoy there me mateys!  A short while back, I wrote a post discussing me initial thoughts on the 2019 Hugo awards.  At that time, I had read none of the works in the best short story category.  I have since remedied the situation and so here be mini-reviews of the short stories and me pick for the 2019 winner.

The short stories are from the list as published on  Click on the story title to read the short stories themselves.

Best Short Story

Thoughts: This is the tale of a young market rat who becomes the court magician.  The story was compelling, clever, and kinda heart-wrenching.  The magic has nasty costs to the user.  The rules of the magic are also complex and fascinating.  I loved this one.  For the first story of this bunch, it sets a high standard.

Thoughts:  These days I don’t normally like tales that involve the fae.  But this one was silly and fun and turned many of the fae tropes sideways.  I also like that it focused on different male fae.  It was light and entertaining.  I am glad I read it but don’t think it should be the winner.

Thoughts:  I was expecting this story to be emotionally devastating but instead it was a fascinating intellectual exercise.  I expected my heart to be shredded and instead my mind was stretched.  Apparently, George Washington (our evil first president) purchased teeth from people for his false dentures.  This story starts with a quote, “‘By Cash pd Negroes for 9 Teeth on Acct of Dr. Lemoire’ –Lund Washington, Mount Vernon plantation, Account Book dated 1784.”  This story explores what the secret lives of the teeth were.  I loved this story and it sent me down a rabbit hole about the history behind Washington’s teeth.  Check out this article to see a picture of Washington’s dentures and to learn more about the history of false teeth.  This was fantastic and be me favourite so far but I am only half-way there.

  • STET,” by Sarah Gailey (Fireside Magazine, October 2018)

Trigger Warning (provided by the publisher): “This story contains references to the death of a child.”

Thoughts:  Okay so this one was rather bizarre, if clever.  This story deals with a piece of legal language where a mother who lost her daughter to a self-driving car, uses her citations to express her feelings about the loss and the problems with AI and the cars’ decision making processes.  For a seemingly short piece, it took me a while to read because of the disjointed structure.  While I did end up thinking this piece was interesting, it was me background in paralegal studies that helped me enjoy this one.  I am not sure how accessible this would be to the reader with no law background.  I can’t say I liked it.  But I am not sad that I read it.  This one will not win.

Thoughts: This certainly gets weirdest title.  And was a fail for me.  It is a fairytale about raptors and it was odd and I couldn’t get into it.  I tried to read it aloud to the first mate to see if that would make it more enjoyable.  It didn’t.  The first mate didn’t like what he heard.  And when I saw how much more I would have to read, I gave up.  I don’t think this writer’s style is for me based on the several others I tried to get through after this one.  I tried three more for curiosity’s sake and did not get through any of them.

Thoughts:  This was an excellent story full of librarians, book love, and caring about the people the world has given up on.  It is bittersweet and full of truths.  I wish the boy and the librarian well.

Now listen up me hearties, the decision has been made:

Hoped for Winner:  As if this is any surprise, “The Secret Lives of the Nine Negro Teeth of George Washington,” by P. Djèlí Clark is me much hoped for winner.  Check it out!

So there ye have it.  Me Hugo thoughts and wishes for short stories.  I think this collection is strong and highly recommend (most of) them.  I will keep y’all posted as I continue readin’ through the Hugo nominees before the winners be revealed on 8/18/19.  In the meantime:

Always remember:

It’s amazing, really, how many bad reputations pirates get.

Why just think of how many of them have been cannonized!

Hardy har har!

x The Captain

25 thoughts on “Shiver me Timbers! The 2019 Hugo Finalists – Part Three – Best Short Story

  1. Great thoughts of the short stories Captain. I find them very interesting but the one about George Washington was quite chilling. Will have to read that one for sure. Good show Captain!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Once again you are a short story enabler! 😉 That’s okay, though, I love reading modern short fiction. I think I need to get a subscription to at least one of these magazines to support the writing and publication of more.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I need more time! I have thought about getting a subscription but I once had a national geographic one (from the ma) and I couldn’t keep up. The good thing about short fiction is that I was able to read all of these stories in a short afternoon. And aye, I am certainly a pusher. Read these!! Arrr!
      x The Captain

      Liked by 1 person

    1. I really think all readers should read that one and the teeth article. Learn something interesting about American history and read a fantastic take on it. I love that history is full of hidden (to me at least) facts that offer more insight into the human condition. And the teeth are such a powerful metaphor about money and power.
      x The Captain

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.